If you care about the planet, the idea of traditional diamonds probably leaves a sour taste. After all, mining is a process that scars landscapes, guzzles resources, and often exploits communities that live close to the mining sites.

So what are you supposed to do when you’re looking for an engagement ring; compromise on elegance and beauty in order to make more ethical choices? Not at all – today, there are plenty of eco-friendly diamond alternatives that are just as pretty as diamonds themselves (because let’s face it, while bad for the planet, they sure do sparkle prettily).

Here are five diamond alternatives that will allow you to honor your values while still slipping on a ring that turns heads.

1. Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds are visually (and chemically) identical to mined diamonds, but thankfully, they have a fraction of their environmental impact. These stones are treated in controlled environments so they skip the destructive mining process entirely. Some labs even power their operations with renewable energy, making them a top-tier choice for sustainability-conscious couples.

Price-wise, lab-grown diamonds are generally more affordable than mined diamonds, leaving room in your budget for other splurges (like a greener honeymoon). If you’re in the market for a sustainable ring, GoodStone is a good choice.

Known for their heirloom-quality jewelry, they have beautiful lab-grown diamond options for every style. Whether you prefer a minimalist style or something more intricate, you can choose lab-grown stones and pair them with gold, platinum, or other premium materials.

2. Moissanite

If brilliance is your main goal, moissanite might be your perfect match. This gemstone is second only to diamonds in hardness and outshines them in sparkle thanks to its higher refractive index. Moissanite is entirely lab-created, so it avoids the environmental and ethical issues linked to traditional diamonds.

It also tends to be more affordable, meaning you can opt for a larger stone without worrying about inflating your carbon footprint. We love moissanite because with it, you get eye-catching beauty and peace of mind – what’s not to love?

3. Recycled Diamonds

Recycled diamonds are another option to consider. These gems are often sourced from vintage jewelry, then cleaned and recut to match modern tastes. In other words, while they’re diamonds, at least they’re repurposed stones that are already in circulation – no environmental costs of new mining.

This is a great option if you don’t want to compromise on the clarity or color of your ring. Plus, you’ll have the added satisfaction of owning a piece with a (hi)story.

4. Ethical Gemstones

Who says an engagement ring needs to feature a diamond or something resembling a diamond? Ethical gemstones like sapphires, rubies, or emeralds offer a stunning and colorful alternative. If sourced from responsible mines or created in labs, these stones can serve as a unique and equally meaningful centerpiece.

While not as hard as diamonds, many gemstones (especially sapphires) are plenty durable for daily wear. Pair them with ethical gold and you’ll have a unique, colorful ring that doesn’t compromise on sustainability.

5. Alternative Natural Stones

Finally, for something unconventional but still natural, consider salt-and-pepper diamonds. These gems feature unique inclusions that give them a speckled, almost celestial appearance. Since they’re less in demand than traditional diamonds, mining them often involves less waste and fewer resources.

While not everyone appreciates the non-traditional look, salt-and-pepper diamonds have a raw beauty that’s perfect for someone who loves to stand out. They’re a good way to embrace sustainability while breaking free from the cookie-cutter mold.

Making Your Choice

In the end, an engagement ring is deeply personal, so it’s crucial that it reflects your values as much as your style. Lab-grown diamonds, moissanite, and other ethical alternatives are all great choices as they ensure you can wear your commitment proudly without compromising the planet or its people.

Saying “yes” should never feel like you’re saying “no” to sustainability. With these alternatives, you can have both.